Vince’s Substack
Vince’s Substack
Are You Sure?
0:00
-6:43

Are You Sure?

A song about Doubt Cannot Be Given the Certainty It Demands

The distinction I’d keep very sharp is: the body is not used to prove the thought wrong. It reveals the machinery that makes the thought feel urgent. Once that whole event is seen, doubt can remain without automatically becoming a problem that thought must solve.

Story: The Question That Couldn’t Be Answered

Verse 1

At three seventeen the question came

without knocking at the door:

Are you sure you’ve really seen it?

Are you sure there isn’t more?

I answered with experience

I answered with the view

I answered with a thousand things

I’d already found were true

Then doubt put on another coat

and softly answered, “Yes—

but are you sure your certainty

is not another guess?”

So thought argued with thought again

until the morning blue

every answer fed the question:

Yes, but are you sure?

Chorus

Are you sure?

Are you sure?

Doubt keeps asking for a cure

every answer builds another

little doorway to unsure

Feel the throat

feel the chest

let the question come to rest

not because the answer’s certain

but because it needn’t be addressed

Are you sure?

Maybe not.

Let that be the thought you’ve got.

No final judge is waiting

for the perfect final thought

Verse 2

The sentence seemed intellectual

a puzzle to be solved

so I polished every argument

until the next evolved

I searched for contradiction

I checked what I had seen

while underneath the courtroom

the body pulled unseen

A tightening near the breastbone

a jaw that wouldn’t loose

a leaning towards tomorrow

with an urgent need for proof

the body rang the alarm bell

and the mind translated through:

Something here is dangerous.

You’d better think this through.

Verse 3

Then underneath:

Am I awake?

another question came:

Will I ever stop the hurting?

Was this journey all in vain?

Can I finally rest now?

Will I lose what I have found?

Will I die still searching

while the others gather round?

The doubt had worn a scholar’s robe

but underneath the dress

was an organism asking:

Am I finally safe yet?

No syllogism answered

what the trembling wanted most

so I stopped debating shadows

with the courtroom’s clever ghost

Bridge

Thought is not the enemy.

Body is not king.

Both are little movements

in the happening

A sentence

then a tightening

an image

then a need

a thought that says:

Answer me

as though answering would free

No need to make the chest relax

no need to clear the head

no need to turn sensation

to another path ahead

Let the doubt be doubtful

let the jaw be tight

nothing has to settle

to make this moment right

Verse 4

The question came next Tuesday:

Maybe you’ve deceived yourself.

I felt the heat behind the face

instead of reaching for the shelf

of arguments and teachings

I’d assembled through the years

and there beneath the sentence

was the ordinary fear

It did not make the statement true

it did not make it false

it only showed the old response

that followed on its course

same words

same little question

same body learning through

but less of an examiner

and more a thought in view

Chorus

Are you sure?

Are you sure?

Doubt keeps asking for a cure

every answer builds another

little doorway to unsure

Feel the throat

feel the chest

nothing here must pass a test

not because the doubt is banished

but because it can be left

Are you sure?

Maybe not.

That’s another passing thought.

Certainty was never hidden

in the answers that you sought

Verse 5

At three forty-two one morning

the old visitor returned:

Are you sure?

The chest contracted

as it had so often learned

the blanket warm around me

a distant motor passed

the question waited for the trial

that always followed fast

But no lawyer took the podium

no argument began

no one proved awakening

or produced a final plan

the question stayed unanswered

then quietly lost its glue

not solved

not crushed

not conquered—

just no longer something

I had to do

Final Chorus

Are you sure?

I don’t know.

Watch the little question go

or watch it stay and chatter

while the breathing rises slow

There is thought

there is chest

there is fear that wants a rest

there is no requirement

that certainty come next

Are you sure?

Maybe not.

Nothing missing from that thought.

Doubt can lose its authority

without an answer being caught

Outro

No verdict.

No decree.

No certainty

to rescue me.

A question forms.

A body moves.

No final thought

has things to prove.

And doubt, once starved

of endless thought,

doesn’t need to be resolved—

it simply

isn’t fought.

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?