Vince’s Substack
Vince’s Substack
Thought Belongs Here Too
0:00
-6:47

Thought Belongs Here Too

A song about Thought Is Also Experiencing

Story: The Sixth Window

A particularly clean pointer from this is: “Thought is actual; its content is conceptual.” That preserves the richness of thinking without confusing the map with what it describes.

Verse 1

I heard them say come back again
get out of your head
feel the floor beneath your feet
forget the words instead
so every time a thought appeared
I treated it as wrong
like thinking was a stranger
that had wandered through the song

I watched the breath
I felt the chair
I listened to the rain
then thought appeared:

I’m thinking now

and spoiled the thing again

Until one day the question came
so obvious and new:

If everything is happening here
doesn’t thought belong here too?

Chorus

Thought belongs here too
memory and view
every little sentence
every thing the mind can do

The story may point elsewhere
but the story happens here
the future is a thought now
the memory now appears

No need to throw the thinking out
to make experiencing true

Sight and sound
and touch and thought

thought belongs here too

Verse 2

The sentence:

Something’s missing

came with pressure in the chest
I used to call the pressure real
and throw away the rest
but words were also happening
a rhythm in the mind
actual as words appearing
though the missing thing I couldn’t find

The thought was real as thinking
not necessarily as fact
the map was really on the table
that didn’t make it the actual track
and suddenly the difference
was simple, clean, and clear:

the story may be somewhere else
but storytelling happens here

Chorus

Thought belongs here too
memory and view
every little sentence
every thing the mind can do

The story may point elsewhere
but the story happens here
the future is a thought now
the memory now appears

No need to throw the thinking out
to make experiencing true

Sight and sound
and touch and thought

thought belongs here too

Verse 3

I travelled back to childhood
without leaving my old chair
father’s voice came through the years
and tightened something there
the past was not returning
though it felt so close and strong
a memory was happening now
with sadness moving on

Then tomorrow came to visit
with a hundred things to fear
none of them had happened
but imagining was here
the mind can cross a thousand years
while never leaving now
every past and future scene
is present somehow

Bridge

Feeling is not holier
thinking is not sin
there isn’t some pure kingdom
that the intellect can’t enter in

Understanding happens
confusion happens too
calculation, recognition
all are forms life travels through

Even the thought:

I’ve got it!

even:

I don’t understand

even:

This is merely intellectual

appears exactly where I am

No thinker on the outside
no witness keeping score
just thinking as a movement
among a million movements more

Verse 4

So let the body tighten
let the sentence make its claim
let analysis investigate
and memory speak a name
let intellect be brilliant
let intellect be wrong
none of it stands separate
from the living of the song

A concept is a brushstroke
not the landscape it describes
but brushstrokes too are part of life
when brush and canvas rise
nothing needs removing
nothing banished from the view
even this understanding—

thought belongs here too

Final Chorus

Thought belongs here too
every why and who
every explanation
every intellectual view

The story may contain a world
that isn’t present here
but the thinking of that world
is something presently clear

No need to stop the mind
to make the immediacy true

Grass and breath
and grief and maths

thought belongs here too

Outro

A sound

a thought

a memory

a view

an understanding forming

then dissolving too

No inside

no outside

no thinker passing through

just this—

sometimes silent

sometimes thinking

thought belongs here too.

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?